Indonesians Explore Plans to Move Capital

14 January, 2018

For many years, Indonesians have talked and dreamed of moving their capital.

Jakarta, on the island of Java, became the capital when Indonesia declared its independence from the Netherlands in the 1940s. The city, formerly called Batavia, was once an important Dutch colonial port. So nationalist leaders had an easy time agreeing on its home to the new Indonesian government.

But since then, Indonesia's capital has been an unending nightmare for city planners. Jakarta is the world's second-largest metropolitan area. But it is sinking -- up to 18 centimeters every year.

The design of the city and its road system has created a near-permanent traffic jam. The Jakarta Transportation Agency estimates those delays cost the government, businesses and the city's residents $11 billion a year.

In this Sept. 24, 2010 photo, motorists are stuck in traffic jam during an evening rush hour at the main business district in Jakarta, Indonesia.
In this Sept. 24, 2010 photo, motorists are stuck in traffic jam during an evening rush hour at the main business district in Jakarta, Indonesia.

Yet Jakarta remains Indonesia's economic center. It is easily the largest city and provides more jobs than anywhere else in the country.

The slow improvement of roads, public transportation and other infrastructure has led most Indonesians to wonder whether it is possible to move the capital.

In 2017, after years of flooding, Indonesian President Joko Widodo asked for the National Development Planning Agency, or BAPPENAS, to study land on the island of Borneo. The main candidate for a new capital is Palangkaraya, a city in Central Kalimantan province. Years ago, even former president Sukarno imagined the city as Indonesians' capital.

Widodo has said little about the project. Yet he admitted on Twitter last year that discussions have begun.

"We are still carrying out the study on what it would take to relocate the capital," said BAPPENAS Minister Bambang Brodjonegoro last year. "But it would be outside Java for sure."

The island of Java is the economic and population center of Indonesia, which has over 15,000 islands in all.

"Preferably the new capital is in a central location within Indonesia, not too far East or West," said Brodjonegoro.

His comments would rule out Sumatra, the largest island. Sumatra is west of Java and home to several important cities and natural resources.

Indonesia lies on what is known as the "Ring of Fire," an area with many volcanoes, and where earthquakes are common. However, Borneo is farther away from the tectonic plates that cause most of the earthquakes and volcanic explosions.

Last week, the governor of Central Kalimantan said that his province is preparing 500 hectares of land if the government decides to move the capital.

Many countries have moved their capitals throughout modern history. One example is the United States. In 1800, the U.S. capital city was moved from Philadelphia to Washington, D.C.

In Southeast Asia, Myanmar, also known as Burma, moved its capital from Yangon to Naypyidaw in 2005. In North Africa, Egyptians are building a new capital in the desert outside Cairo.

Some critics think the dream of moving Indonesia's capital is part of a desire by some people to revisit the Sukarno era.

Writer Johannes Nugroho believes Indonesians are experiencing a longing for Sukarno and his leadership.

It was a "time when Indonesia was a major player on the international stage," he says. "I think the desire to revisit Palangkaraya as a new capital city stems from the same nostalgia, to finish what Sukarno started."

The writer added that Sukarno thought Indonesians needed to break with the past and have a fresh start.

There would be great economic and geopolitical costs to moving the capital from Java to Kalimantan. Most importantly, Indonesia shares Borneo with Malaysia and Brunei, and the political balance is delicate.

Central Kalimantan has very low sea access for a nation of islands.

"Political parties would have to move out," noted Indonesian Vice President Yusuf Kalla last year. "Courts and Supreme Courts would also have to move, aside from the president. Military bases would also have to move. There would be hundreds of thousands who would need housing and offices," he added.

And finally, developing Palangkaraya or a nearby area would cause environmental damage on Borneo. Palm oil and other industries have already cleared land, destroying forests where many animals lived. The island is home to many endangered species, such as the Borneo orangutan.

Some Indonesians wonder if relocating the capital may mean simply moving problems from one island to another.

I'm Susan Shand and I'm Dorothy Gundy.

Krithika Varagur reported this story for VOA. Susan Shand adapted it for Learning Engloish. Mario Ritter was the editor.


Words in This Story

Infrastructuren. the roads, structures and public services that are needed for a city of area to operate properly

Delicate adj. easily broken or damaged

Tectonic plates - n. structures in the Earth's surface that move, float, and break, causing earthquakes, volcanoes,

Nightmare – n. a frightening dream

Traffic jam – n. a situation where a long line of vehicles have stopped moving or are moving very slowly

Location – n. a position or place

Resource – n. something that can be used to increase one's wealth

Era – n. a time or period

Nostalgia – n. a desire or longing for something from the past

Access – n. permission or ability to en